Robotic Adrenalectomy vs. Traditional Surgery: Which Option is Best for Adrenal Gland Disorders?
By Dr. Anup Ramani
When it comes to adrenal gland disorders, choosing the right surgical method is crucial. The adrenal glands, which sit atop the kidneys, play a vital role in hormone production, and disorders such as adrenal tumors, hyperplasia, or pheochromocytoma often require surgical intervention.
Traditionally, open surgery or laparoscopic approaches were used to remove the affected adrenal glands, but advancements in robotic surgery have introduced robotic adrenalectomy as a promising alternative. This article compares robotic adrenalectomy with traditional open and laparoscopic surgeries to help patients and doctors make informed decisions about the best treatment options for adrenal gland disorders.
Understanding Adrenal Gland Disorders
Adrenal gland disorders often manifest as hormone imbalances, which can lead to a wide range of symptoms including high blood pressure, weight gain, anxiety, and even more serious conditions like Cushing’s syndrome or primary aldosteronism.
When these disorders are caused by tumors or other abnormalities in the adrenal glands, surgery is often the recommended treatment. The goal of the surgery is to remove the adrenal gland or tumor while minimizing damage to surrounding structures and preserving overall health.
What is Robotic Adrenalectomy?
Robotic adrenalectomy is a Minimal invasive procedure that uses robotic technology to assist surgeons in removing the adrenal gland or tumors with enhanced precision. The surgeon controls robotic arms equipped with surgical instruments through small incisions in the patient’s abdomen. This approach allows for greater dexterity and precision compared to traditional methods, particularly in complex or delicate procedures.
What is Traditional Adrenal Surgery?
Traditional adrenal surgery typically refers to two methods: open surgery and laparoscopic surgery. Open surgery involves a large incision to provide the surgeon direct access to the adrenal gland, while laparoscopic surgery uses small incisions and a camera (laparoscope) to perform the surgery. Open surgery is often reserved for larger or more complicated tumors, whereas laparoscopic surgery is less invasive and more commonly used for smaller tumors.
Comparing Robotic Adrenalectomy with Traditional Open Surgery
Invasiveness and Scarring
- Robotic Adrenalectomy: Robotic surgery is a Minimal invasive procedure, involving small incisions of less than an inch in length. This leads to significantly reduced scarring, which is often a primary concern for patients. The small incisions also lower the risk of infection and reduce postoperative pain.
- Open Surgery: In contrast, open surgery requires a much larger incision, often extending from the abdomen to the rib cage. This leads to more visible scarring, greater tissue trauma, and a higher risk of complications such as infections or hernias.
Precision and Control
- Robotic Adrenalectomy: Robotic technology provides surgeons with enhanced control and precision. The robotic system offers a 3D view of the operating area and allows for fine, controlled movements that are difficult to achieve with human hands alone. This level of precision is especially beneficial in adrenal surgery due to the small size and delicate location of the adrenal glands.
- Open Surgery: While open surgery provides direct access to the adrenal gland, it lacks the enhanced visual clarity and precision of robotic surgery. Surgeons rely on their manual dexterity, which may be less accurate than the robotic system, especially in tight or complex anatomical spaces.
Pain and Recovery Time
- Robotic Adrenalectomy: Due to the smaller incisions and less invasive nature of the surgery, patients generally experience less pain postoperatively. The recovery time is also shorter, with most patients resuming normal activities within two to four weeks. Patients undergoing robotic adrenalectomy in Mumbai or other top-tier facilities in India often report minimal discomfort and quick returns to daily life.
- Open Surgery: Recovery from open surgery takes significantly longer, often six to eight weeks. The larger incision increases postoperative pain and requires a longer hospital stay. Patients are also at a higher risk of developing complications like wound infections or hernias.
Comparing Robotic Adrenalectomy with Laparoscopic Surgery
Visualization and Precision
- Robotic Adrenalectomy: One of the major advantages of robotic surgery over traditional laparoscopic surgery is the 3D high-definition visualization provided by the robotic system. This allows the surgeon to view the surgical area in greater detail, which is especially important when navigating around critical structures such as blood vessels and nerves near the adrenal glands. The robotic instruments can also rotate more freely than the standard laparoscopic instruments, allowing for more precise movements.
- Laparoscopic Surgery: While laparoscopic surgery also uses small incisions and offers a faster recovery time compared to open surgery, the 2D view and less flexible instruments can limit the surgeon’s ability to perform complex tasks with the same level of accuracy as robotic surgery.
Surgeon Fatigue and Efficiency
- Robotic Adrenalectomy: The robotic system reduces surgeon fatigue by allowing them to operate from a console, rather than standing for long periods. This can improve focus and efficiency during lengthy procedures. For complex adrenal gland cases, robotic adrenalectomy surgeons in India are seeing an increase in success rates thanks to the reduced strain and increased control provided by robotic systems.
- Laparoscopic Surgery: While effective, laparoscopic surgery can be more physically demanding for the surgeon due to the manual operation of the instruments. This may increase the risk of human error, especially in longer procedures or more complex cases.
Patient Outcomes and Safety
Success Rates
- Robotic Adrenalectomy: Studies have shown that robotic adrenalectomy has high success rates, particularly in the removal of smaller, benign tumors and for patients requiring precise excision of tissue. The enhanced precision of the robotic system can reduce the risk of damaging surrounding organs, leading to fewer complications.
- Traditional Surgery: Both laparoscopic and open surgeries have high success rates as well, particularly when performed by experienced surgeons. However, robotic surgery tends to offer better outcomes in terms of lower blood loss, fewer complications, and shorter hospital stays.
Postoperative Complications
- Robotic Adrenalectomy: Due to its Minimal invasive nature, robotic adrenalectomy generally results in fewer postoperative complications, such as infection, bleeding, or hernias. Patients also have a lower risk of experiencing chronic pain after surgery.
- Traditional Surgery: Open surgery carries a higher risk of complications due to the larger incision and more invasive nature of the procedure. Laparoscopic surgery, while Minimal invasive, does not offer the same precision as robotic surgery, which could result in a higher risk of complications if the procedure is complex.
Cost Considerations
- Robotic Adrenalectomy: One of the main drawbacks of robotic surgery is the cost. The advanced technology and specialized training required for robotic adrenalectomy surgeons can make the procedure more expensive than traditional surgery. However, in places like India, the cost of robotic surgery is still more affordable than in many Western countries, making Adrenal Gland treatment in India a viable option for international patients.
- Traditional Surgery: Open and laparoscopic surgeries are generally less expensive than robotic surgery due to the lower cost of equipment and training. However, the longer hospital stays and extended recovery times may offset some of the initial savings.
Conclusion: Which Option is Best?
When deciding between robotic adrenalectomy and traditional surgery, the choice depends on several factors, including the complexity of the adrenal gland disorder, the size of the tumor, and the patient’s overall health.
- Robotic adrenalectomy is typically the best option for patients who need a Minimal invasive approach with precise control, especially in cases involving smaller tumors or complex locations. The shorter recovery time and reduced risk of complications make it an appealing choice for many patients. Those seeking Adrenal Gland Surgery in Mumbai or in India will find top facilities offering robotic adrenalectomy with skilled surgeons at the helm.
- Traditional laparoscopic surgery is still a option for smaller or straightforward tumors where the advanced capabilities of a robotic system may not be necessary. It offers a good balance of cost-effectiveness and shorter recovery times, although it lacks the enhanced precision of robotic surgery.
- Open surgery is generally reserved for larger or more invasive tumors where access to the entire adrenal gland is needed. While it involves more risk and longer recovery times, it remains a necessary option for certain complex cases.
Ultimately, the best surgical approach will depend on the patient’s unique condition, the surgeon’s recommendation, and the available resources.
FAQs - Robotic Adrenalectomy
Is robotic adrenalectomy better than traditional surgery?
Robotic adrenalectomy offers greater precision, smaller incisions, and faster recovery compared to traditional surgery.
How long is the recovery after robotic adrenalectomy?
Most patients recover within two to four weeks after robotic adrenalectomy, significantly shorter than the six to eight weeks typical of open surgery.
Are there any risks with robotic adrenalectomy?
While generally safer due to its precision, risks include bleeding, infection, and damage to surrounding organs, though these are less common than in traditional surgery.
Is robotic adrenalectomy available in India?
Yes, robotic adrenalectomy is available in many top hospitals across India, especially in cities like Mumbai, where patients can find highly skilled surgeons and cutting-edge technology.
How does laparoscopic adrenalectomy compare to robotic surgery?
Laparoscopic surgery is less invasive than open surgery but does not offer the same level of precision as robotic surgery, making it less ideal for complex cases.
Best Uro-Oncological surgeon
Specialist in India for Robotic Surgery
MCh, DNB, MS, DNB
Dr. Anup Ramani
CONTACT
Dr. Anup Ramani
Uro-Oncologist in India,
Best Robotic Surgeon for Uro Oncology Surgery
1407, One Lodha Place Next to World Towers Senapati Bapat Marg, Worli, Mumbai. 400013.
Uro-Oncologist in India,
Best Robotic Surgeon for Uro Oncology Surgery
1407, One Lodha Place Next to World Towers Senapati Bapat Marg, Worli, Mumbai. 400013.
Dr Anup Ramani @ Copyright 2024 – SEO by Opal Infotech
PARTIAL PENECTOMY
- Partial penectomy is done in cases where glans and distal penis is involved with carcinoma.
- Partial penectomy is a type of organ-preserving surgery. Preservation of sexual and micturational function depends on the surgical dissection and reconstruction of residual urethra.
Kidney Stone Removal
- Patients who develop stones in the kidney or ureter, often experience severe pain.
- This condition usually needs a procedure to remove the kidney stones.
- This procedure is called ureteroscopy and is performed very commonly.
- It does not require any cuts and hence it is painless.
- The procedure is performed with an endoscope inserted through the penis under spinal anesthesia.
- The scope is inserted through the penis into the kidney and stones are dissolved with a laser.
- The procedure takes about 40-50 minutes.
- A catheter (urine pipe) is kept after the procedure to drain the bladder. A stent is kept in the kidney at the same time.
- Patient is mobile and walking in the room the same evening.
- Hospital stay is one night and patient is discharged the next day after removal of the catheter.
- Patient has to come back after six weeks to remove the stent in the kidney.
- Patients can resume office a week after surgery and heavy activities like running, weight lifting, a month after the procedure.
- We offer fixed packages for this procedure which can be obtained by calling our helpline +91 9967666060.
- Men with an enlarged prostate, which is a normal ageing changes, often experiencing difficulty passing urine. This condition usually needs a procedure to trim the prostate and relieve the blockage.
- This procedure is called TURP and is performed very commonly.
- It does not require any cuts and hence it is painless.
- The procedure is performed with an endoscope inserted through the penis under spinal anaesthesia.
- The overgrown prostate is dissolved with a laser bloodlessly.
- The procedure takes about 40 minutes.
- A catheter (urine pipe) is kept after the procedure to drain the bladder.
- Patient is mobile and walking in the room the same evening.
- Hospital stay is two nights and patient is discharged with the catheter, which is removed after 4 days.
- Patients can resume office a week after surgery and heavy activities like running, weight lifting, a month after the procedure.
- We offer fixed packages for this procedure which can be obtained by calling our helpline +91 9967666060.
ROBOTIC ADRENALECTOMY FOR ADRENAL GLAND TUMOUR
-
Robotic adrenalectomy is a sophisticated, complex surgery and it is very important that an experienced surgeon performs this surgery to avoid major complications.
-
Once the anesthesia is done, and patient positioned, three micro cuts (3mm each) are made in the patient’s abdomen.
-
The arms of the Da Vinci robot are connected to the cuts via ports (tubes).
-
Dr. Ramani then sits in the controlling console to perform the surgery.
-
On an average, a robotic adrenalectomy takes one hour.
-
The surgery is almost completely bloodless and there has never been any need to transfuse blood after surgery.
-
A urine catheter and bag to drain the bladder is inserted during surgery.
-
A tiny drain pipe may be inserted in the surgical side of the abdomen, connected to a bag.
-
Patient is kept nil-by-mouth the day of the surgery, with IV fluids. Sips of water are started the next day and solid food by day three.
-
The drain pipe, if kept, is removed in the room on day 2 after surgery.
-
The catheter is removed on day two after surgery.
-
Total hospital stay for robotic adrenalectomy is 4 nights (including night before surgery).
-
Post discharge, a doctor from the surgical team visits the patient at home/ hotel room once every day.
RETURN TO ACTIVITY
On the day of discharge, patient is totally self-sufficient. They are able to walk freely without any pain, dress themselves, shower, toilet and they do not need to hire any nurse or help at home. Almost all patients are back to work within 2 weeks of surgery.
Heavy activities like running, weight lifting can be resumed after a month
FOLLOW UP AFTER SURGERY
Follow up after an adrenalectomy is in the form of CT scans, once a year for 5 years.
Local patients usually meet Dr. Ramani after two weeks to discuss report.Outstation patients are counselled on a phone consultation.
ROBOTIC SURGERY FOR BLADDER CANCER
- Dr. Ramani is one of the very few surgeons in India who has the expertise to perform a robotic surgery for bladder cancer, which includes removing the urinary bladder and reconstructing a new bladder robotically.
- Robotic radical cystectomy is an extremely sophisticated, complex surgery and it is very important that an experienced surgeon performs this surgery to avoid major complications.
- Once the anaesthesia is done, and patient positioned, six micro cuts (3mm each) are made in the patient’s abdomen.
- The arms of the Da Vinci robot are connected to the cuts via ports (tubes).
- Dr. Ramani then sits in the controlling console to perform the surgery.
- On an average, a robotic radical cystectomy with an ileal conduit takes 3-4 hours.
- The surgery is almost completely bloodless and there has never been any need to transfuse blood after surgery.
- A urine catheter and bag to drain the new bladder is inserted during surgery.
- Two tiny drain pipe in inserted in the surgical side of the abdomen, connected to a bag.
- Patient is kept nil-by-mouth for 4 days after surgery with IV supplementation of patient’s daily requirements of calories, fats, carbohydrates, proteins and electrolytes.
- The drain pipes are removed in the room on day 3-5 after surgery.
- Total hospital stay for radical cystectomy is 8 nights (including night before surgery).
- Post discharge, a doctor from the surgical team visits the patient at home/ hotel room once every day.
RETURN TO ACTIVITY
- On the day of discharge, patient is totally self-sufficient. They are able to walk freely without any pain, dress themselves, shower, toilet and they do not need to hire any nurse or help at home.
- Almost all patients are back to work within 6 weeks of surgery. Heavy activities like running, weight lifting can be resumed after two months.
FOLLOW UP AFTER SURGERY
Follow up after a radical a cystectomy is in the form of CT scans, once a year for 5 years.
Histopathology report: Local patients usually meet Dr. Ramani after two weeks to discuss report.
Outstation patients are counselled on a phone consult. Depending on the report, patient may or may not need chemotherapy after surgery.
If chemo is needed, patients may choose to get it done with a medical oncologist of their choice or avail the services of one of the four medical oncologists on our team.
ROBOTIC RADICAL/PARTIAL NEPHRECTOMY FOR KIDNEY CANCER
- Robotic partial nephrectomy is a sophisticated, complex surgery and it is very important that an experienced surgeon performs this surgery to avoid major complications. Robotic radical (total) nephrectomy is
- relatively easier but still requires significant experience to consistently deliver results.
- Once the anaesthesia is done, and patient positioned, five micro cuts (3mm each) are made in the patient’s abdomen.
- The arms of the Da Vinci robot are connected to the cuts via ports (tubes).
- Dr. Ramani then sits in the controlling console to perform the surgery.
- On an average, a robotic radical nephrectomy takes one hour and a robotic partial nephrectomy takes about an hour and half.
- The surgery is almost completely bloodless and there has never been any need to transfuse blood after surgery.
- A urine catheter and bag to drain the bladder is inserted during surgery.
- A tiny drain pipe in inserted in the surgical side of the abdomen, connected to a bag.
- Patient is kept nil-by-mouth the day of the surgery, with IV fluids. Sips of water are started the next day and solid food by day three.
- The drain pipe is removed in the room on day 3 after surgery. The catheter is removed on day two after surgery.
- Total hospital stay for radical/partial nephrectomy is 4 nights (including night before surgery).
- Post discharge, a doctor from the surgical team visits the patient at home/ hotel room once every day.
RETURN TO ACTIVITY
- On the day of discharge, patient is totally self- sufficient.
- They are able to walk freely without any pain, dress themselves, shower, toilet and they do not need to hire any nurse or help at home.
- Almost all patients are back to work within 2-3 weeks of surgery.
- Heavy activities like running, weight lifting can be resumed after a month.
FOLLOW UP AFTER SURGERY
- Follow up after a radical/partial Nephrectomy is in the form of CT scans, once a year for 5 years.
- Local patients usually meet Dr. Ramani after two weeks to discuss report.
- Outstation patients are counselled on a phone consultation.